Are German Shepherds Good Family Dogs?
What to Know Before Getting One...
I watched Heart of the Beast, the film starring Brad Pitt, and most of the time I was thinking, “How the hell did they train the dog to do that?”
I turned to my friend sitting next to me, who also has a Shepherd, and said, “This is so unrealistic. Since when has a German Shepherd staring at something ever made a situation better?”
If you live with a Shepherd, you might know exactly what I mean…
Films can make owning a German Shepherd look pretty impressive. But there's a difference between watching a carefully selected and trained dog on screen and living with one in the real world. And I sometimes wonder how much research people actually do before deciding to get one.
If you're thinking about getting a German Shepherd, a quick Google search will tell you that they're intelligent, loyal, protective and eager to work.
All lovely qualities. But is that enough to decide whether a German Shepherd is the right dog for you?
What about the barking, the alertness to movement, the tendency to chase or follow things, and the difficulty some dogs have switching off? These are the traits worth understanding before bringing one home.
Understanding German Shepherd behaviour
German Shepherds were developed as working dogs, with a history that includes herding and guarding. Their working heritage has shaped many of the qualities people admire, including their intelligence, responsiveness and awareness of their surroundings.
But those qualities can also present challenges in everyday life.
Most of German Shepherds are highly alert to movement. They notice people getting up, children running, dogs playing or cats darting across a room. For some, watching isn't enough. They may follow, chase, block, bark or try to control where another animal or person goes.
These behaviours can have different causes, including herding-related tendencies, chasing, guarding or high arousal. Not every German Shepherd will display them, and breed alone cannot explain an individual dog's behaviour.
The important thing to understand is that a dog who notices movement may also feel compelled to act on it.
Imagine trying to relax in the evening when your dog reacts every time someone gets up from the couch. Or living with a dog who constantly follows the cat (that’s the best case scenario) or struggles to leave another dog alone.
These aren't necessarily signs of a bad dog, but they can be difficult to manage, particularly when you have a large, powerful breed.
Living with a German Shepherd and other pets
This is something I know from personal experience.
My German Shepherd, Vinnie, was rehomed because he was too intense with the cat in his previous home. I'm so grateful to his previous owner for recognising that the situation wasn't working and making the decision to find him another home as soon as they did. That decision gave him the opportunity to find a home where his needs could be accommodated. Knowing what Vinnie was like when he arrived, it probably would’ve taken months to make things manageable and safe. If ever...
When Vinnie arrived, I already had two dogs. After seeing how intensely he wanted to engage, I decided not to mix them together straight away.
It took six weeks of very hard work to integrate him.
And the work didn't stop there.
Vinnie now lives with a smaller dog- a Spaniel, so I'm mindful of how he uses his body around her. He's a large, powerful dog, and when he's not feeling his best ( when his tummy is not right), he can struggle more to control his movements and also his sharp end. What might be an ordinary movement from Vinnie could have a very different impact on a smaller dog.
I need to pay attention to how he's feeling, manage interactions when necessary and avoid assuming that because things went well yesterday, they'll automatically go well today.
I love living with Vinnie. He is a great companion, but making this arrangement with a smaller dog in the house work takes thought and ongoing management. That's simply part of living with this particular dog.
If you have cats or other dogs, consider whether you're prepared for the possibility that introductions may take time and that separation or supervision may remain necessary.
Are German Shepherds good family dogs?
German Shepherds can make wonderful family companions, but the breed alone can't tell you whether an individual dog will suit your household.
Think about what everyday life looks like in your home. Do you have young children who run and play? Other pets who need their own space? Frequent visitors or a busy household?
Stimulation doesn't just happen outside the house. Children playing, people moving between rooms, other animals and everyday household noise can all affect how a dog copes.
Some German Shepherds manage this comfortably. Others may become overexcited, vigilant or vocal, or find it difficult to settle.
If you have children, supervision and safe spaces are essential. When introducing a dog to other pets, use gradual introductions and appropriate barriers, lead and prevent chasing or unwanted interactions. Don't assume everyone will work things out for themselves.
The aim is to create a household where both the dog and the people and animals around them can feel safe.
What do German Shepherds need beyond exercise?
German Shepherds need appropriate physical activity, but exercise alone isn't enough.
They also benefit from mental stimulation, opportunities to explore, training and learning how to settle. The right balance depends on the individual dog's age, health, temperament and experience.
More activity isn't always the answer to a dog who struggles to switch off. If a dog is already highly aroused, continually adding excitement may make it harder for them to learn to relax.
A suitable routine should include:
Physical exercise and opportunities to explore.
Mental enrichment, such as scent activities, training and problem-solving.
Rest and a quiet place to relax without constant interruptions.
Life skills that help the dog cope with everyday situations.
The aim isn't to keep your dog busy every waking minute. It's to meet their needs while helping them manage life in your home and the wider world.
How much time and patience does a German Shepherd need?
Bringing a dog home is a long-term commitment. Six weeks of puppy classes can be a useful start, but they won't produce a finished dog or prepare them for every situation they'll encounter.
Training needs to continue in everyday life, and new challenges may appear as a dog matures or their circumstances change.
Before getting a German Shepherd, be realistic about the time you can give to training, enrichment and helping them adjust to your lifestyle. Consider whether you can manage their environment when needed and seek qualified help if their behaviour becomes difficult to handle safely.
This isn't about putting people off the breed. It's about understanding what the commitment involves before making it.
Choosing the right German Shepherd for you
Two German Shepherds can have very different temperaments, experiences and needs. One may be comfortable around other dogs, while another may need careful management. One may settle easily in a busy home, while another may find everyday activity difficult.
If you're considering a puppy, ask responsible breeders about health, temperament, parent dogs and the traits they're aiming to produce.
If you're considering an adult or rescue dog, ask about their behaviour around children, unfamiliar people and other animals, as well as any known challenges. Remember that how a dog behaves in one setting doesn't guarantee how they'll behave in another.
Most importantly, look beyond the qualities you find attractive.
Ask yourself:
Can I meet this breed's physical and mental needs?
Can I manage the behaviours this particular dog may display?
Will this dog suit my household, including any children or other pets?
Am I prepared to adapt my routine if life with this dog turns out to be more challenging than expected?
So, are German Shepherds the right dog for you?
The question isn't simply whether German Shepherds are intelligent, loyal or good family pets. It's whether you can meet the needs of the individual dog you're bringing home.
Vinnie is a wonderful addition to my life, but I'm also aware of the work involved in helping him live successfully alongside my other dog.
Choosing a dog isn't about finding one that fits a perfect picture in your head. It's about understanding what living with that dog might involve and deciding whether you're ready for it.
Because researching a breed isn't just about finding out what makes it appealing. It's about understanding the parts that might be harder to live with, too.
Sandra @Lothian Dog Training
Comments